REVIEWS


"This remarkable book is a passionate call for the recovery of the Catholic tradition of passionate spiritual search. With her intensely personal and unflinchingly honest writing, the author encourages the seeker on a journey through suffering and joy, darkness and loneliness, towards enlightenment and union. Her special friends and guides on the difficult yet wonderful journey are the Beguine mystics of the fourteenth century, and other eccentric and (as she says) 'weird' friends, ancient and contemporary. This is a book for now: the author refuses to stick with no longer relevant spiritual metaphors or to accept once revered spiritual practices just because they are old. There is a freshness here, and a delightfully frank humor, but most of all a passionate love."
-Rosemary Luling Haughton, PhD (honorary), theologian, author of The Passionate God, The Catholic Thing, Gifts in the Ruins

"Many Christians play it safe by practicing a tepid, no-risk spirituality in which we domesticate the roaring Lion of Judah into a nice, safe pussycat. Susan Pitchford’s beautifully written book reminds us that an authentic relationship with God, others, and self depends on an embrace of whole-bodied desire on the one hand and the possibility of suffering on the other. This is a book that liberates us to let God be both the passionate Lover and the Roaring Lion God is."
-Kerry Walters
Author of The Art of Dying and Living

"There be in God, some say, a deep but dazzling darkness.’ The 17th century poet Henry Vaughan expresses a vital truth, which is explored with intelligence, passion and humor by Susan Pitchford. In spite of her disclaimers to be a theologian, her book is a discerning work of the moral and theological imagination. It is an exploration well suited for our times, marked as they are, by both shallowness and fierceness in religion. The God of God in the Dark is passionate and intractably mysterious. And because we are all made in that divine image, so we too are driven by passion to embrace the unknown. Spirituality isn’t a ‘product.’ It can neither be bought nor sold and Susan Pitchford skewers this misunderstanding with down-to-earth accessible writing, marked with humor and honesty. The book is refreshing and yet stands in a long mystical tradition. It is a great gift for a floundering, atomized culture—water in the desert."
-Alan Jones
Dean emeritus of Grace Cathedral, San Francisco
Honorary canon of the Cathedral of Our Lady of Chartres
Author of Soul Making: The Desert Way of Spirituality

"In an accessible style, laced with rich metaphors, wry humor, and down-to-earth explanations, Susan Pitchford guides the reader to a fresh knowledge and appreciation of the Christian mystical journey. Since mysticism is about relationships, it inevitably involves passion (the enemy of boredom and apathy), whose two faces are desire (God desires us infinitely more than we desire God), and suffering (life’s pain can be understood in positive, life-giving ways).
Pitchford advocates a return to the mystical metaphor of the spiritual marriage in a 21st century framework—an evocative, potentially enriching challenge. Intimacy with God is viewed in an inclusive way that resists the attitude that one size fits all. Rather, mysticism is a way of intense prayer open to all the baptized called and willing to follow the path of desire for God in their daily lives.
Pitchford takes a balanced approach to affirmative and negative prayer forms, but she focuses on the positive or kataphatic way that she believes has been neglected. Her favorite exemplars include her ‘spooky sisters’—medieval beguines such as Beatrijs of Nazareth, Hadewijch of Brabant, Mechthilde of Magdeburg, and Marguerite Porete; Teresa of Avila and Mother Teresa; Francis of Assisi and John of the Cross. This book is an antidote to contemporary cynicism and indifference, a goad to those who desire to infuse their spirituality with new life and vigor."
-Elizabeth Dreyer
Department of Religious Studies
Fairfield University, Connecticut

"Susan R. Pitchford has penned (or at least word processed!) a new book with a master’s touch in God in the Dark. Coming from a Franciscan orientation she has tapped into a broad spectrum of the ancient mystical heritage of Christianity in a way that speaks to the average person in a fast paced, modern world. Readers will find it a fine addition to their modern mystical books, or a great introduction to the mystical tradition for new seekers and first time readers."
-John Michael Talbot
Founder, and Spiritual Father
The Brothers and Sisters of Charity at Little Portion Hermitage

"Pitchford first draws inspiration from the medieval semilay sisterhood of Beguines; then she takes example from the “dark night” mysticism of St. John of the Cross. The whole, however, is convincingly contemporary, eloquent, and reasoned, drawing the reader toward a faith infused by deep desire and acquainted with the suffering that is part of human life. VERDICT Pitchford’s easy style is a boon for her welcome message, which seeks to enrich Christian experience; excellent for Christians readers and pastors."
-Spiritual Living Reviews, March 1, 2011

This is an excellent book by Pitchford. She brilliantly weaves the two themes of suffering and desire together throughout, and shows us how they're really just two sides of passion.

She reminds us that God's purpose in driving us into the dark is always done out of love, and .."that God never leads us into the dark to abandon us, but only to draw us closer." (pg.115)

The three chapters on suffering are the best in the book, and chapter 8, MIDNIGHT IN THE DESERT is absolutely brilliant. Pitchford also chronicles her struggle with back pain while overseas away from home, and shows the reader how God always stood by her and never left her.

My only quibble with the book is that about half way through, the author inserts a 4-letter swear word..not a huge deal but would rather not see something like that in a Christian book.

Well worth reading and savoring the lessons about suffering in the dark.
-Joel Holtz review on amazon.com

Released March 2011: God In the Dark: Suffering and Desire in the Spiritual Life


A look at passion - conceived as both desire and suffering - in the spiritual life.

“Eros is one of God’s names.” The late Dorothee Soelle wrote these words in "Mysticism and Resistance," and Christian writers are increasingly meeting God under this strange and ancient name. A growing number of books address either our longing for God or our grief when suffering comes and God seems far away. What is lacking is work that shows the relationship between our longing and our grief. "God in the Dark" portrays suffering and desire as the two faces of passion, and passion itself as the essential energizing force of the spiritual life.

Western Christianity in the twenty-first century urgently needs to know both sides of passion. The religious routines, partisan squabbling and mundane daily upkeep of the institutional church often obscure the passionate love at the heart of the gospel. Overburdened by the demands of our lives, we settle for an hour of peace each week over intimacy with the living God, and what began as a love affair cools into a banal religious complacency. "God in the Dark" invites readers to reconsider the God whom the Bible describes as both “love” (I John 4:8) and a “consuming fire” (Hebrews 12:29).

There is also an acute need among spiritual seekers for a better understanding of suffering, especially spiritual suffering. Many people were shocked to learn through her letters that Mother Teresa had spent much of her life in a state of spiritual darkness. The struggle to reconcile this with her reputation for holiness reveals that the role of darkness and suffering in the spiritual life is not widely understood. "God in the Dark" invites readers to reinterpret the dark nights of their lives, to learn that darkness is not necessarily a place of failure and abandonment, but can be a place of intimacy and growth. When we learn that God does some of his best work in the dark, we will be drawn there by our desire, and when the night closes in around us, we will welcome its embrace.


My work

General Spirituality
God in the Dark: Suffering and Desire in the Spiritual Life
A look at the two faces of passion (suffering and desire), and their role in the life of faith.
Franciscan Spirituality
Following Francis: The Franciscan Way for Everyone
Reflections on Franciscan spirituality and the Franciscan Third Order
Identity Tourism
Identity Tourism: Imaging and Imagining the Nation -- June, 2008
This book examines how museums and other attractions can be used to tell a people's story, and build a sense of national identity.
Work in Progress: Tourism
Guilt Trip: Telling Atrocity Stories Through Tourism
Examines how museums tell the stories that are hardest to hear.
Selected social science articles
Selected articles
A selection of articles on the creation and projection of group images and identities in tourist attractions, and on methods for the study of new religious movements.